The Premier League has always been full of drama: last-minute goals, wild comebacks, unexpected heroes, and heartbreak. It’s the kind of league where anything can happen on any given day. Now and then, a pattern breaks through the chaos.
A rare thread of consistency. A quiet superstition backed by numbers.
Some players do not just score goals; they seem to carry a kind of luck, a hidden charm. When they find the net, their team doesn’t lose. Not even once.
It’s not about who scored the most or who has the best highlight reels. This is something different. This is about players whose goals never went to waste.
Every time they hit the back of the net, the team walked away with at least a point, more often, all three. These are not just scorers. They’re streak-holders. Game-changers. Mood-shifters. Their finishing touch never came with defeat.
Across decades and different clubs, these six names have carved out a special kind of unbeaten magic. A goal from them? That was the sign of a good day.
1. Gabriel Jesus
62 Games Scored In – Won 57, Drew 5, Lost 0
Jesus might not always make headlines the way Haaland or Salah do, but quietly, consistently, he’s written his name into Premier League history. When Jesus scores, his team wins or, at the very least, avoids defeat.
Sixty-two times he’s found the net in England’s top flight. Not once has he walked off the pitch on the losing side after scoring.
That’s no small feat.
It helps, of course, that Jesus spent the bulk of his Premier League career under the wing of Pep Guardiola at Manchester City, a team built on dominance and precision.
With the likes of Kevin De Bruyne feeding him and City’s relentless control of possession, Jesus was able to thrive in a system that didn’t just encourage goals, but demanded them.
Still, even after his switch to Arsenal, that streak held strong.
The Gunners, resurgent under Mikel Arteta, have leaned into Jesus’ experience and versatility. And every time he scores, it’s like a signal that the team is doing something right. His goals aren’t just finishing touches; they’re statements of control, momentum, and belief.
A 91.9% win rate in matches he’s scored in puts him near the very top.
Only Pedro and Antonio Valencia boast a higher ratio among those who’ve scored in 20+ games without tasting defeat.
Gabriel Jesus, the man with four Premier League titles, is also the man who’s never scored in vain.
SEE ALSO | 7 Most Exciting Premier League Games of the 2024/25 Season
2. James Milner
54 Games Scored In – Won 43, Drew 11, Lost 0
James Milner is football’s equivalent of a Swiss army knife; always useful, rarely flashy, quietly essential.
Across two decades and five clubs – Leeds United, Newcastle, Aston Villa, Manchester City, and Liverpool – Milner has scored in 54 Premier League matches. And not once has his team lost when he’s hit the net. It’s almost absurd when you stop and think about it.
Milner is the kind of player managers love and fans admire.
He doesn’t crave the spotlight, yet he always turns up in these unique statistics. Whether it’s making the most Premier League appearances, converting clutch penalties, or, in this case, delivering undefeated scoring appearances, Milner finds a way into the conversation.
His goals weren’t always spectacular, but they were timely. Be it a cool finish during a frantic top-four battle or a penalty in a gritty away match, Milner’s contributions had weight.
He scored important goals, ones that meant something in the context of the season.
Even now, at Brighton & Hove Albion, in the twilight of his career, Milner remains a steady presence. He hasn’t scored for the Seagulls yet, but who knows? If he does, history tells us Brighton won’t be losing that day.
3. Diogo Jota
52 Games Scored In – Won 43, Drew 9, Lost 0
There’s something about Diogo Jota — a calm, calculating aura that makes him seem like he’s always just about to do something lethal.
Fifty-two times he’s scored in Premier League games, and fifty-two times his side has avoided defeat. That’s not just luck. That’s impact.
Jota’s rise in England began with Wolves. In his first Premier League season, he announced himself with energy and goal—scoring in 12 different games without a single defeat. That’s remarkable for a player in a newly promoted side.
Then came Liverpool. Under Klopp, Jota slotted in like he’d always belonged. He brought something different to the frontline of established stars. He was sharp in tight spaces, clinical in the box, and his movement made him unpredictable.
He scored seven goals in his first 10 Liverpool appearances. He became the first player since Robbie Fowler to score in each of his first four Premier League home games for the Reds. Every goal seemed to spark something — whether a comeback, a seal on the result, or just a surge in belief.
Now that he’s no longer with us, this record becomes more than just a stat; it becomes a permanent part of Premier League history, carved with quiet reverence.
SEE ALSO | Diogo Jota’s 7 Greatest Moments for Liverpool: A Farewell Too Soon
4. Darius Vassell
46 Games Scored In – Won 36, Drew 10, Lost 0
For some, Darius Vassell is a name that sparks memories of early 2000s football: Villa Park, baggy kits, and England’s golden generation that never quite delivered.
Buried beneath the nostalgia is a record few others can match.
Vassell scored in 46 different Premier League games during his time at Aston Villa and Manchester City. His team never lost when he scored. Not once.
He was never prolific; 52 goals in 265 appearances isn’t headline-grabbing. But it’s the impact that counts. Vassell’s goals were good omens. They tilted matches in his team’s favor, shifted momentum, and often brought results.
His most famous moment might not even be a Premier League one; it’s that missed penalty in Euro 2004, the gut-wrenching shootout against Portugal. But in the Premier League, he was a quiet lucky charm.
A player who, when on song, made sure his team stayed on track.
Even when he scored in a 3-2 defeat for Leicester against Nottingham Forest, it didn’t ruin this particular record. That loss came in the Championship.
In the top flight, Vassell was undefeated whenever he found the net.
5. Gabriel Martinelli
37 Games Scored In – Won 30, Drew 7, Lost 0
Gabriel Martinelli is easy to overlook. In a team filled with expressive midfielders, vocal defenders, and headline-makers like Bukayo Saka, Martinelli keeps his head down and works.
If you look closely, you’ll find a stat that speaks louder than any celebration ever could.
In the 37 Premier League games Martinelli has scored in, Arsenal have never lost.
Thirty wins. Seven draws. No defeats.
He brings energy, no doubt. His pressing is relentless, his movement sharp. It’s his knack for finding the net at crucial moments that gives him real value. His goal at Anfield in May 2025, a cool finish in a frantic game, was his 40th Premier League goal. Another one added to the list of unbeaten contributions.
Martinelli’s presence on this list is not a fluke. It reflects how often he scores at the right time, not to decorate a win, but to create one. He brings balance, not noise. And the numbers don’t lie.
When he scores, Arsenal breathe a little easier.
SEE ALSO | Premier League: 10 Fastest Title Wins of All Time
6. Salomon Kalou
32 Games Scored In – Won 29, Drew 3, Lost 0
SKalou arrived at Chelsea with a mix of hype and curiosity. He wasn’t the flashiest forward, and he didn’t always start every match, but when he did play, he contributed often in crucial ways.
Kalou’s goals came across 32 different Premier League matches. Chelsea won 29 of those and drew the other three. No defeats.
Playing in a team as dominant as Chelsea during those late-2000s seasons certainly helped, but Kalou’s role wasn’t as passive as some might assume. He often popped up in key moments, a tap-in at the far post, a sudden run behind the defence, a goal to kill off the contest.
He only hit double digits once in a Premier League season, but his consistency in impact made him a trusted weapon. Under José Mourinho, he matured, adapted, and became a player who could change a game without needing to star in it.
One Premier League title, multiple cup wins, and this strange, wonderful record to his name, Salomon Kalou was the kind of player who quietly made good things happen.
SEE ALSO | 10 Greatest Premier League Managers in History (So Far)
