The Premier League’s Barclays era produced its share of superstars, title winners, and record-breakers, though some of its most memorable characters belonged to a different category. They were the players who made neutral supporters stop changing channels, gave smaller clubs an identity and occasionally turned an ordinary Saturday afternoon into something worth remembering for years.
Between 2001 and 2016, the league became a stage for footballers whose personalities and unusual talents made them household names, even when their trophy collections remained modest. There was a Nigerian magician at Bolton, a Senegalese striker capable of scoring goals that defied geometry, and a Stoke midfielder who made taking a throw-in feel like defending a penalty.
The Barclays era had room for all of them. Some delivered spectacular performances for several seasons, others enjoyed brief spells of brilliance, while a few became legends through one particular skill that opposition managers struggled to contain.
10. Adel Taarabt
Morocco | Attacking midfielder | QPR: 2009–2015

Adel Taarabt played football as though somebody had permitted him to ignore the usual instructions, and watching him at his best could leave defenders looking rather uncomfortable about their career choices.
The Moroccan arrived at Queens Park Rangers after struggling to establish himself at Tottenham, eventually making his move permanent in 2010. His extraordinary 2010–11 Championship campaign produced 19 goals and 16 assists, earning him the Football League Player of the Year award and helping QPR secure promotion.
His Premier League performances were less consistent, although the technical ability remained obvious whenever he found space to operate. Taarabt could beat opponents with a change of direction, slip through crowded areas with ridiculous close control and attempt passes that most players would have abandoned before considering them.
His goals against Arsenal and Tottenham during QPR’s 2011–12 survival campaign helped establish his reputation among Premier League supporters. He was unpredictable, occasionally frustrating and almost impossible to ignore when everything clicked.
QPR supporters remember him as one of the finest talents to represent the club, a fitting tribute to a footballer whose ability often seemed larger than the tactical instructions surrounding him.
SEE ALSO | 10 Tallest Players in the Premier League (2026/27)
9. Michu
Spain | Forward | Swansea: 2012–2015

Michu arrived at Swansea City from Rayo Vallecano in the summer of 2012 for approximately £2 million, and within months, the Spanish forward had become one of the Premier League’s most talked-about attacking players.
His first season was extraordinary. Michu scored 18 Premier League goals in 2012–13, finishing among the division’s leading scorers while helping Swansea establish themselves as a serious top-flight side.
What made him particularly effective was his ability to operate between midfield and attack, arriving in dangerous positions with excellent timing and finishing chances with the composure of someone who had been playing in England for years.
He also scored in Swansea’s 2013 League Cup final victory over Bradford City, becoming part of the club’s first major domestic trophy success.
Then came the injuries. His subsequent seasons were disrupted by ankle problems, and the explosive form that had made him a sensation proved difficult to recover.
Michu’s Premier League career never reached the heights of that remarkable debut campaign, although 18 goals in one season and a League Cup winner’s medal provided enough memories to secure his place in Swansea folklore.
8. Morten Gamst Pedersen
Norway | Winger | Blackburn: 2004–2013

Blackburn Rovers supporters had a special relationship with Morten Gamst Pedersen, whose left foot could produce the sort of deliveries that made defending against Blackburn particularly unpleasant.
Signed from Tromsø in 2004, the Norwegian quickly established himself as one of the division’s most dangerous wide players, combining powerful shooting with excellent crossing and an unusual ability to score directly from corners.
Pedersen was particularly effective during Blackburn’s mid-2000s resurgence under Mark Hughes, when the club regularly competed for European qualification and developed a reputation for making life difficult for the Premier League’s biggest sides.
His spectacular strikes became a familiar feature of Blackburn’s campaigns, while his set-piece delivery gave strikers such as Benni McCarthy and Roque Santa Cruz plenty to work with.
There was something wonderfully old-fashioned about Pedersen’s game. He could spend an afternoon delivering crosses from the left before suddenly producing a 25-yard strike that left the goalkeeper with little chance.
Blackburn supporters enjoyed nine years of that left foot, and the Premier League gained another character whose best moments were often worth watching repeatedly.
SEE ALSO | How Much Does a Premier League Club Lose After Relegation?
7. Dimitri Payet
France | Attacking midfielder | West Ham: 2015–2017

Dimitri Payet spent only two Premier League seasons with West Ham United, although his first campaign produced the sort of performances that supporters remember long after the player has moved elsewhere.
Signed from Marseille in 2015, the Frenchman quickly became the creative heartbeat of Slaven Bilic’s side, bringing an unusual combination of technical control, imagination and extraordinary dead-ball ability to a team enjoying an excellent final season at Upton Park.
His free kicks became must-watch television. Payet could bend the ball around walls, disguise his intended direction and generate enough power to leave goalkeepers scrambling, even when they appeared to have positioned themselves correctly.
During the 2015–16 campaign, he scored nine Premier League goals and supplied 12 assists, helping West Ham finish seventh in their final season at their historic home.
His performances also helped make the club’s farewell to Upton Park memorable, particularly as West Ham repeatedly challenged established sides with a brand of attacking football built around his creativity.
Payet eventually returned to Marseille in January 2017, leaving behind a collection of extraordinary highlights and a West Ham fanbase that had quickly developed an affection for its French playmaker.
6. Papiss Cissé
Senegal | Striker | Newcastle: 2012–2016

Papiss Cissé’s introduction to English football was so spectacular that Newcastle United supporters could have been forgiven for wondering whether their January signing had arrived with some previously undiscovered finishing technique.
The Senegalese striker joined from Freiburg in January 2012 and immediately formed a devastating partnership with Demba Ba, helping Alan Pardew’s side mount an unexpected challenge for Champions League qualification.
Cissé scored 13 goals in his first 12 Premier League appearances, an extraordinary return that included a brace against Chelsea at Stamford Bridge in May 2012.
The second goal became one of the defining strikes of the Barclays era. Receiving the ball from Jonas Gutiérrez at an awkward angle, Cissé opened his body and curled an outrageous outside-of-the-boot effort into the far corner, leaving Petr Čech with practically no opportunity to respond.
Even Didier Drogba, watching from the Chelsea substitutes’ area, appeared impressed by what had just happened.
Cissé’s subsequent seasons were less productive, although that remarkable introduction had already secured his place among Newcastle’s memorable modern-era forwards. His Chelsea goal remains the sort of strike that makes supporters revisit old Premier League compilations.
SEE ALSO | 10 Greatest Managers in Premier League History
5. Rory Delap
Republic of Ireland | Midfielder | Stoke: 2006–2013

FOR EDITORIAL USE ONLY Additional licence required for any commercial/promotional use or use on TV or internet (except identical online version of newspaper) of Premier League Football League photos. Tel DataCo +44 207 2981656. Do not alter/modify photo.alter/modify photo. (Photo by IAN KINGTON / AFP via Getty Images)
Rory Delap became one of the Premier League’s most recognisable cult heroes through a skill that most professional footballers barely consider worth practising.
His long throws transformed Stoke City into one of the most uncomfortable opponents in the division after their promotion in 2008, with Tony Pulis recognising an opportunity to turn a simple restart into a dangerous attacking weapon.
Delap possessed an extraordinary throwing technique, capable of sending the ball deep into crowded penalty areas with the speed and trajectory of a well-struck cross. Stoke’s tall, physical players were perfectly suited to attacking those deliveries, creating problems for defenders who suddenly had to organise themselves against something resembling a corner kick.
Arsenal, Chelsea and Manchester United all experienced the difficulties of defending Stoke’s approach, while Arsène Wenger became particularly vocal about the threat posed by Delap’s deliveries.
The midfielder’s throws became so influential that opposition teams often struggled to clear the first delivery, allowing Stoke to maintain pressure around the penalty area.
Football has always rewarded unusual specialists, and Delap demonstrated that a player could become a Premier League household name without scoring spectacular goals or producing elaborate dribbling tricks.
His arms did most of the talking.
4. Hatem Ben Arfa
France | Winger | Newcastle: 2010–2015

Hatem Ben Arfa was the kind of footballer who could spend 20 minutes struggling to influence a match before producing one moment that made everybody in the stadium sit forward.
The French winger arrived at Newcastle in 2010, initially on loan from Marseille, bringing a reputation for exceptional dribbling ability and an occasionally frustrating relationship with consistency.
His Newcastle career was interrupted by a serious leg injury suffered against Manchester City in September 2010, which kept him out for much of the remainder of that season. However, when he returned, supporters were treated to glimpses of the extraordinary ability that had made him such an exciting prospect.
His finest Premier League moment arrived against Bolton Wanderers in April 2012, when he collected the ball inside his own half, accelerated past several opponents and finished calmly after covering approximately 70 metres.
It was an astonishing solo goal, combining balance, acceleration, close control and the confidence to keep running when defenders appeared to have every opportunity to stop him.
Ben Arfa also scored an outstanding individual effort against Blackburn Rovers in the FA Cup, further establishing his reputation as one of English football’s most entertaining dribblers.
His career never fully matched his natural ability, although Newcastle supporters received enough moments of brilliance to understand why his talent generated so much excitement.
3. Yakubu Aiyegbeni
Nigeria | Striker | 4 Premier League clubs: 2003–2012

Aiyegbeni was one of the most dependable goalscorers of the Barclays era, combining physical strength, intelligent movement and an unusually relaxed approach to finishing chances.
The Nigerian striker first established himself at Portsmouth, where his goals helped the club become a competitive Premier League side following promotion in 2003. He subsequently enjoyed productive spells at Middlesbrough and Everton before producing another excellent campaign with Blackburn Rovers.
His Premier League record deserves considerably more attention than it sometimes receives. Yakubu scored 95 goals across 252 appearances, representing four different clubs and proving himself capable of delivering goals in several different attacking systems.
His 2007–08 campaign was particularly impressive, scoring 15 league goals for Everton after joining from Middlesbrough, while his 17-goal return for Blackburn in 2011–12 demonstrated that his finishing instincts remained sharp.
Everton supporters developed a special affection for him, with the familiar chant demanding that teammates feed the Yak becoming part of the atmosphere at Goodison Park.
Yakubu possessed the strength to hold off defenders, the awareness to find space inside the penalty area and the composure to finish without appearing particularly troubled by the occasion.
He rarely needed elaborate preparation before shooting. Give him a decent opportunity and there was every chance the goalkeeper would be collecting the ball from the net.
SEE ALSO | Every Premier League Club’s Wage Bill for 2026/27
2. Clint Dempsey
United States | Forward / Attacking midfielder | Fulham: 2007–2012

Clint Dempsey arrived at Fulham from the New England Revolution in January 2007, and over the following six years, he became one of the most productive American footballers ever to play in the Premier League.
His game combined intelligent movement, physical determination and an eye for spectacular finishes, making him an important figure during Fulham’s most successful modern European campaign.
Dempsey scored 50 Premier League goals for Fulham, including 17 during the 2011–12 season, which remains the highest single-season Premier League goalscoring total by an American player.
However, his contribution extended beyond domestic football. Fulham reached the 2010 UEFA Europa League final after eliminating several established European clubs, including Juventus in one of the competition’s most memorable comebacks.
Dempsey scored the decisive late goal in Fulham’s famous 4-1 victory over Juventus at Craven Cottage, delicately chipping the ball over goalkeeper Antonio Chimenti to complete a remarkable turnaround after losing the first leg 3-1.
Fulham eventually lost the final to Atlético Madrid, although their European adventure established Dempsey as one of the club’s most important modern players.
He also scored against Liverpool on the final day of the 2006–07 season, helping Fulham secure their Premier League survival shortly after arriving in England.
For a club that regularly operated outside the division’s wealthiest group, Dempsey represented an extraordinary combination of consistency, personality and match-winning quality.
1. Jay-Jay Okocha
Nigeria | Attacking midfielder | Bolton: 2002–2006

Jay-Jay was arguably the greatest entertainer of the Barclays era, a footballer whose presence at Bolton Wanderers made a club better known for organisation and physical strength suddenly feel like an exhibition of attacking imagination.
Signed from Paris Saint-Germain in June 2002 on a free transfer, the Nigerian arrived at Bolton with an extraordinary reputation, having already represented his country at the World Cup and impressed supporters across Europe with his technical ability.
Sam Allardyce understood that Okocha offered something different, and the midfielder quickly became central to Bolton’s ambitions of establishing themselves in the Premier League.
His performances were filled with stepovers, disguised passes, outrageous flicks and dribbles that left opponents wondering how they had been beaten. His famous rainbow flick over Arsenal’s Ray Parlour remains one of the most entertaining pieces of skill from that period.
However, reducing Okocha to tricks would overlook his importance to the team. He scored seven league goals during Bolton’s 2002–03 survival campaign, including a spectacular strike against West Ham, and later captained the side during their rise towards the Premier League’s European places.
Bolton finished eighth in 2003–04 and sixth in 2004–05, qualifying for European competition for the first time in the club’s history.
Across four Premier League seasons, Okocha made 124 appearances, scored 14 goals and supplied 11 assists. Those numbers only tell part of the story because his influence extended into the way supporters viewed the club and what they expected from their footballers.
He gave Bolton a personality that stretched far beyond its position in the league table, becoming a favourite among supporters who appreciated his confidence, creativity and infectious enjoyment of football.
For Nigerian football fans, his Bolton years also represented a particularly special chapter in the Premier League’s history. Okocha remains one of the competition’s most recognisable African entertainers, and his name still produces an immediate smile among supporters who watched him play.
So good they named him twice. So entertaining that one name was probably enough.
