I remember one match between Roma and Bologna when José Mourinho made this really surprising decision: he substituted Renato Sanches just 18 minutes after bringing him on. It’s one of those moments that makes you stop for a second and think.
It made me wonder: with something like that happening, could there ever be an instance where a player already substituted out was able to return?
Soccer is not all black and white.
The rules regarding substitutes can be rather confusing, which brings us into today’s question: can a substituted player return to the game?
Soccer is often referred to as “the beautiful game” because of its grace and simplicity, but it is also a sport built around layers of strategy.
Substitutions play an enormous role in that. Managers use them to adjust tactics, give players a breather, or address injuries. However, unlike some other sports, soccer has traditionally had much stricter rules around substitutions.
To determine if players can re-enter a match once subbed out, we need to look at what the rules are, how they have been developed over time, and why they’re that way.
The Basics of Soccer Substitution Rules
To answer the question plainly: in professional soccer, players cannot be substituted back into the game after being taken off.
This fundamental rule has been a cornerstone of the sport for decades. Once a player leaves the field, their involvement in that match is over, barring some very rare exceptions which we’ll explore later.
The standard substitution rules, as outlined by the International Football Association Board (IFAB), are as follows:
- Number of Substitutions: In most modern competitions, a team can make a maximum of five substitutions per game. These must be made during any three stoppages in play, excluding half-time, to prevent undue delays in the game.
- No Re-Entry: A player who has been substituted off the field cannot come back. This is an absolute rule to maintain the flow of the game and avoid abuse of this tactic.
- Injury Substitutions: When a team has used all their substitutions and one of their players sustains an injury, they either have to carry on the match with fewer players or forfeit the match if they cannot be able to field the minimum required number of players normally seven.
- Extra time slots: Some competitions, however, allow for an additional substitution in extra time lots bringing it to six.
These rules balance strategy, player welfare, and the game’s rhythm. But where did they come from, and why is re-substitution not a thing?
The Historical Context of Substitution Rules
Soccer was not always the tactical chess match that it is today.
Substitutions were not even part of the game until the mid-20th century, and if a player got injured before that, his team had to soldier on a man down.
Imagine the chaos of playing a man short in today’s high-stakes games-it’s almost unthinkable.
The first official employment of substitutes in international soccer came in 1954, in a World Cup qualifier between the Soviet Union and Poland.
Over time, the system has evolved, and by the 1970s, more standardized substitution rules were in place across leagues.
The “no re-entry” clause became a norm, which also made sure that there could not be any unfair exploitation thereof.
But why should re-entry not be allowed? Let’s look into that.
SEE ALSO | 10 Best Super-Subs In Soccer History
Why Is Re-Substitution Not Allowed?
The flow of the game
One of the most salient features of soccer is continuous play. Whereas basketball and American football are marked by regular stoppages in play, soccer thrives on continuous action.
Allowing re-substitutions would create constant stoppages in the game, which upsets the rhythm of the game and annoys players and fans alike.
Strategic Integrity
Then again, imagine that a star player could be taken off to rest during a lull and then brought back on for an important last push.
That would be unfair for teams with deeper benches because of more significant financial resources, making the game in some ways about manipulation rather than skills.
Physical and Tactical Demands
Soccer tests not only skill but also endurance and adaptability.
Limited substitutions ensure players and coaches must balance resources and strategy carefully over 90 minutes-plus. It’s a core part of the sport’s challenge.
What If Re-Substitution Was Allowed in Professional Soccer?
Let’s be the devil’s advocate for a second. What if soccer did, allow re-substitutions? The implications would certainly be interesting, to say the least:
Increased Tactical Complexity
Coaches could substitute players in and out during specific phases of a game to take it to new levels. That is to say, when on the back foot, needing a comeback, a player replaces the defensive midfielder, who then takes back his position to protect a lead.
Less Player Fatigue
Players would catch their breath and possibly avoid potential injuries in really high-intensity games, thus prolonging their careers.
Unequal Advantage for Elite Teams
Teams with deeper squads would be able to manipulate the re-substitution rules and overpower teams, increasing disparities in soccer.
Longer Matches
More substitutions will probably mean more stoppages, which could make games drag on a bit and make them less appealing.
How Substitution Rules Influence Coaching Decisions
Pulling Renato Sanches so early was a very bold call by Mourinho. It also brought into the light how fine a line coaches tread when substituting players on and off the pitch.
Do you wait for halftime? Do you make an early adjustment? With only a limited number of changes, every substitution is a gamble.
Consider these scenarios:
- Early Injuries: An injury in the first half can force a coach to use a substitution they’d have preferred to save for later.
- Tactical Adjustments: Coaches substitute players to either change the formation or to counter an opponent’s strategy. These moves are gambles that can make or break a game.
- Managing Fitness: Coaches have to balance winning today’s game with keeping players fresh for upcoming matches amidst tight schedules.
The Emotional Impact on Players
To be substituted-especially early in the game-is often a crushing blow to a player’s confidence. Just think of yourself as Renato Sanches in that Roma-Bologna match, walking off the pitch after only 18 minutes on.
It is a moment that does raise questions of trust, form, and future opportunities.
At the same time, substitutions can be redemptive moments: a player who comes on as a sub may just turn out to be the hero-scores a decisive goal or changes the course of the game.
The history of soccer is replete with super-subs like Ole Gunnar Solskjær and Oliver Giroud whose impact off the bench has attained legendary proportions.
This is, however, still an area in development.
SEE ALSO | Why Does My Soccer Coach Hate Me?
Why a Team Might Substitute a Substitute
Where, during a game, the coach feels that they wish to change the team’s tactics either dramatically or by just a small amount they may feel substituting a player is the best way of achieving what they now want to see happen.
Either they want to bring on an extra forward player to increase the attacking capabilities of the team or want to bring on an extra defender to strengthen the back of the team.
In either case, they need to remove a player from the field because each team is limited to only fielding 11 players at a time.
For this reason, there is no reason a player who has previously been brought on as a substitute could not be the perfect player to make way for another substitute to come on.
This would therefore be a reason for the coach to substitute this player to allow the new substitute to enter the game.
Another reason to substitute a substitute is that the player may be injured.
A soccer player who comes on as a substitute carries the same risk of injury as any other player. There are so many ways a player can get injured in a soccer match.
It could be in a tackle in a sprint up the touchline, or even while waiting for a corner to be taken.
Where an injury has been sustained by a player who has come on as a substitute during the game, then for the good of the player and the team, such a player should be substituted off the field and another player brought on.
If a player does not have an adequate level of fitness, or they came into the game as a substitute near the start of the game, then they may find themselves running out of energy and stamina before the game is over.
If, because of this, they are no longer able to perform at the level required of them, they may be substituted to make way for a player with more energy.
Sometimes a coach will bring on a player as a substitute, but after a while, the coach will feel that that player is not playing well enough to justify their continued inclusion as part of the team.
So, in the interests of the best for the team, the coach will substitute them and replace them with a better player.
SEE ALSO | Do Soccer Players Get Drug Tested? What You Should Know
Can a Substituted Player Come Back On?
The last question that many people want to know is that once a player has been substituted off the field, is it possible for them to come back on again?
A substituted player can’t come back on again in soccer.
In this case, the soccer rules state clearly that a substituted player should proceed directly to the technical area or dressing room and take no further part in the game.
The only times a player may return to the field of play after being substituted is during a youth, veterans, disability, and grassroots soccer game, and even then, it is subject to the agreement of the National Soccer Association, confederation, or FIFA.
